Another incident with more and better info to hunt down the bug:
After a defense 4 of 6 groupmembers received a very small defense tick (11 rps), one member got a huge one (5500 rps), one received nothing because he joined during the fight but was also not at the spot.
Timeline of events:
- Our group of 5 albs went to defend Hlidskialf faste, which was in alb possession.
- much pew pew from the inner keep, killing at least 30 people (group and personal quest finished), both hib and mid.
- just before the keep was taken (approx. 2-3 mins before end of siege) group member 6 was invited but couldn't join at Hlid
- everyone died inside the inner ck to hib charge, hibs eventually took the keep
- defense ticks received before taking another offensive action.
With the new /keeptick command (thank you for this awesome feature!) it looked like this:
Top: members got a tick of 11 (with 0.06% participation)
bottom: one member received a tick of 5500 (with 13.76% participation)
(didn't collect screenshots from the rest of the group members but they all had 11 except the new guy).
However, for some reason everyone with the low tick got listed as ATTACKER, whereas the rp hoover was listed as a DEFENDER. We all defended a keep in our realms possession together, should have defender status. At some point the status seems to have shifted to attacker (since the ticks before were identical among group members).
Maybe this has to do with group members joining/leaving, messing with some internal data list, Malkkie described (among others) similar problems with members leaving/joining.
Hope this helps!